Landmarks | Ii | Lc dev | Lc ctl | Id | B | Pog | Me | Mf dev | Mf ctl | ||||||||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
p value | (ratio) | p value | (ratio) | p value | (ratio) | p value | (ratio) | p value | (ratio) | p value | (ratio) | p value | (ratio) | p value | (ratio) | p value | (ratio) | ||
Nose-related | Al dev | .320 | (.034) | .369 | (.049) | .268 | (.033) | .363 | (.037) | .365 | (.037) | .427 | (.036) | .436 | (.037) | .305 | (.046) | .251 | (.049) |
Al ctl | − .219 | (− .008) | − .159 | (− .011) | − .135 | (− .007) | − .301 | (− .008) | − .284 | (− .008) | − .284 | (− .008) | − .246 | (− .008) | − .212 | (− .010) | − .151 | (− .011) | |
Pn | .049 | (.015) | .196 | (.022) | .008 | (.015) | .155 | (.016) | .310 | (.017) | .264 | (.016) | .253 | (.017) | .242 | (.021) | .168 | (.022) | |
Sn | .383 | (.146) | .378 | (.209) | .260 | (.140) | .388 | (.156) | .324 | (.158) | .430 | (.153) | .427 | (.157) | .202 | (.195) | .169 | (.209) | |
Lip-related | A’ | .603* | (.192) | .510 | (.275) | .455 | (.184) | .571 | (.206) | .470 | (.207) | .530 | (.201) | .532 | (.207) | .350 | (.256) | .343 | (.275) |
Ls | .718** | (.307) | .580 | (.440) | .612* | (.294) | .705* | (.329) | .630* | (.332) | .701* | (.321) | .703* | (.331) | .520 | (.410) | .503 | (.440) | |
Stms | .500 | (.310) | .470 | (.445) | .455 | (.298) | .479 | (.333) | .431 | (.336) | .542 | (.325) | .540 | (.335) | .292 | (.415) | .265 | (.445) | |
Ch dev | .395 | (.851) | .585* | (1.220) | .361 | (.816) | .347 | (.914) | .219 | (.921) | .340 | (.892) | .349 | (.917) | .389 | (1.138) | .194 | (1.220) | |
Ch ctl | .288 | (.364) | .302 | (.522) | .590* | (.349) | .265 | (.391) | .390 | (.394) | .418 | (.382) | .422 | (.393) | .360 | (.487) | .366 | (.522) | |
Stmi | .660* | (.322) | .570 | (.462) | .651* | (.309) | .662* | (.346) | .586* | (.349) | .604* | (.337) | .601* | (.347) | .485 | (.431) | .509 | (.462) | |
Li | .650* | (.379) | .602* | (.544) | .626* | (.364) | .641* | (.407) | .608* | (.411) | .695* | (.398) | .697* | (.409) | .490 | (.508) | .476 | (.544) | |
Chin-related | B′ | .685* | (.452) | .606* | (.648) | .590* | (.434) | .680* | (.486) | .729** | (.490) | .727** | (.474) | .735** | (.488) | .540 | (.605) | .538 | (.648) |
Pog’ | .788** | (.609) | .700* | (.874) | .610* | (.585) | .790** | (.654) | .776** | (.660) | .878*** | (.639) | .846*** | (.657) | .665* | (.815) | .628* | (.874) | |
Me’ | .765** | (.686) | .597* | (.984) | .544* | (.658) | .777** | (.737) | .742** | (.743) | .833*** | (.719) | .850*** | (.740) | .595* | (.918) | .583* | (.984) | |
Cheek-related | Zy dev | .389 | (.065) | .353 | (.093) | .278 | (.063) | .394 | (.070) | .310 | (.071) | .403 | (.068) | .399 | (.070) | .232 | (.087) | .195 | (.093) |
Zy ctl | .062 | (.034) | .145 | (.049) | .216 | (.033) | .118 | (.037) | .101 | (.037) | .078 | (.036) | .069 | (.037) | .189 | (.046) | .216 | (.049) | |
Ck dev | .458 | (.077) | .279 | (.110) | .265 | (.074) | .418 | (.082) | .329 | (.083) | .359 | (.080) | .375 | (.083) | .348 | (.103) | .344 | (.110) | |
Ck ctl | − .329 | (− .061) | − .192 | (− .088) | − .203 | (− .059) | − .295 | (− .066) | − .173 | (− .066) | − .206 | (− .064) | − .246 | (− .066) | − .260 | (− .082) | − .313 | (− .088) |