Landmarks | Ii | Lc dev | Lc ctl | Id | B | Pog | Me | Mf dev | Mf ctl | ||||||||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
p value | (ratio) | p value | (ratio) | p value | (ratio) | p value | (ratio) | p value | (ratio) | p value | (ratio) | p value | (ratio) | p value | (ratio) | p value | (ratio) | ||
Nose-related | Al dev | − .121 | (.125) | − .129 | (.122) | − .405 | (.100) | − .289 | (.100) | − .216 | (.107) | .147 | (.109) | − .013 | (.107) | − .101 | (.124) | − .336 | (.097) |
Al ctl | .011 | (.050) | .098 | (.049) | .110 | (.040) | .216 | (.040) | .214 | (.043) | .310 | (.044) | .451 | (.043) | .152 | (.050) | .196 | (.039) | |
Pn | .304 | (− .006) | .520 | (− .006) | .616* | (− .005) | .550 | (− .005) | .549 | (− .005) | .531 | (− .005) | .508 | (− .005) | .440 | (− .006) | .547 | (− .005) | |
Sn | − .229 | (.018) | − .009 | (.018) | − .035 | (.015) | − .129 | (.014) | − .082 | (.016) | .038 | (.016) | .145 | (.015) | − .171 | (.018) | − .146 | (.014) | |
Lip-related | A’ | − .475 | (.036) | .026 | (.035) | .119 | (.029) | − .008 | (.029) | − .021 | (.031) | .105 | (.032) | .227 | (.031) | − .098 | (.036) | − .073 | (.028) |
Ls | .042 | (.079) | .196 | (.077) | .242 | (.063) | .119 | (.063) | .108 | (.067) | .135 | (.069) | .315 | (.067) | − .060 | (.078) | .087 | (.061) | |
Stms | .696* | (.206) | .665* | (.200) | .510 | (.165) | .500 | (.164) | .590* | (.176) | .591* | (.179) | .390 | (.176) | .628** | (.205) | .389 | (.159) | |
Ch dev | .215 | (.387) | .591* | (.377) | .320 | (.311) | .357 | (.309) | .386 | (.331) | .512 | (.337) | .563 | (.330) | .415 | (.386) | .212 | (.300) | |
Ch ctl | .165 | (.583) | .397 | (.568) | .596* | (.468) | .422 | (.465) | .363 | (.498) | .380 | (.508) | .417 | (.497) | .155 | (.580) | .387 | (.451) | |
Stmi | .598* | (.825) | .590* | (.804) | .675* | (.662) | .617 * | (.659) | .555 | (.705) | .413 | (.719) | .547 | (.704) | .290 | (.821) | .601* | (.638) | |
Li | .760** | (.855) | .641* | (.833) | .600* | (.686) | .605 * | (.683) | .550 | (.731) | .512 | (.745) | .325 | (.730) | .492 | (.851) | .530 | (.661) | |
Chin-related | B’ | .789** | (.855) | .739* | (.833) | .725** | (.686) | .823*** | (.683) | .822** | (.731) | .748** | (.745) | .560 | (.730) | .738** | (.851) | .721** | (.661) |
Pog’ | .731** | (.881) | .699* | (.859) | .622* | (.707) | .730** | (.704) | .769** | (.753) | .771** | (.768) | .644* | (.752) | .692** | (.878) | .620* | (.682) | |
Me’ | .323 | (.593) | .287 | (.578) | .150 | (.476) | .221 | (.473) | .258 | (.507) | .413 | (.517) | .405 | (.506) | .220 | (.590) | .125 | (.459) | |
Cheek-related | Zy dev | .168 | (− .042) | − .017 | (− .041) | − .305 | (−.034) | − .158 | (− .034) | − .081 | (− .036) | .199 | (− .037) | .175 | (− .036) | .014 | (− .042) | − .209 | (− .033) |
Zy ctl | .444 | (.046) | − .079 | (.045) | − .050 | (.037) | .088 | (.037) | .110 | (.040) | .010 | (.040) | .156 | (.040) | .079 | (.046) | .184 | (.036) | |
Ck dev | .150 | (.238) | .383 | (.232) | .121 | (.191) | .030 | (.190) | .042 | (.203) | .201 | (.207) | .093 | (.203) | .090 | (.237) | − .143 | (.184) | |
Ck ctl | .165 | (.163) | − .039 | (.159) | − .165 | (.131) | − .173 | (.130) | − .158 | (.140) | − .180 | (.142) | − .011 | (.139) | − .137 | (.163) | − .180 | (.126) |