Skip to main content

Table 1 Attractiveness ranking of photographs according to the groups

From: Effects of different nose types on class II treatments for female patients

Ranking of attractiveness

Orthodontist (mean ± standard deviation)

Plastic surgeon (mean ± standard deviation)

Lay persons (mean ± standard deviation)

1

OS4 (83.23 ± 15.89)

OS4 (78.97 ± 12.54)

OS4 (80.88 ± 13.62)

2

OS3 (80.97 ± 13.93)

OS3 (78.53 ± 14.27)

OS3 (79.50 ± 23.71)

3

OS1 (63.16 ± 14.73)

OS2 (67.79 ± 17.67)

CT3 (62.88 ± 19.98)

4

OS2 (62.68 ± 14.87)

CT3 (64.26 ± 16.42)

OS2 (60.88 ± 26.06)

5

PT4 (60.14 ± 17.02)

PT4 (62.85 ± 15.78)

PT4 (60.74 ± 21.03)

6

PT3 (58.32 ± 13.13)

OS1 (62.35 ± 14.62)

OS1 (59.91 ± 23.93)

7

CT3 (56.13 ± 14.35)

PT3 (62.35 ± 13.77)

CT4 (57.21 ± 24.65)

8

CT4 (55.81 ± 15.22)

CT4 (59.68 ± 16.03)

PT3 (56.62 ± 24.04)

9

PT1 (50.97 ± 16.45)

PT1 (55.09 ± 14.06)

CT1 (50.29 ± 25.16)

10

OS5 (50.97 ± 14.45)

CT2 (53.91 ± 17.73)

PT2 (47.79 ± 24.47)

11

CT1 (50.90 ± 15.40)

CT1 (53.74 ± 16.04)

PT1 (45.68 ± 26.11)

12

CT2 (46.13 ± 14.58)

PT2 (50.74 ± 20.23)

CT2 (42.65 ± 25.05)

13

OS6 (43.29 ± 17.31)

OS5 (49.26 ± 17.01)

OS5 (29.94 ± 20.11)

14

PT2 (43.06 ± 12.95)

OS6 (44.06 ± 16.63)

PT5 (26.91 ± 24.46)

15

PT5 (40.81 ± 15.65)

PT5 (42.29 ± 15.64)

OS6 (26.18 ± 21.07)

16

CT5 (37.26 ± 12.09)

PT6 (37.74 ± 15.52)

PT6 (25.15 ± 18.23)

17

PT6 (36.71 ± 12.24)

CT5 (37.06 ± 16.79)

CT5 (24.44 ± 16.86)

18

CT6 (31.13 ± 14.06)

CT6 (36.76 ± 14.86)

CT6 (20.47 ± 14.84)

  1. PT pre-treatment, CT camouflage treatment, OS (orthognathic surgery)