Skip to main content
Progress in Orthodontics

Table 2 Comparison of the current study tip torque and in-out values with other studies

From: Optimal parameters for final position of teeth in space closure in case of a missing upper lateral incisor

Measure

Author

EmpiricalD

MinD

Difference

Measure

Author

EmpiricalD

MinD

Difference

U1 Tip

Andrews

0.73

0.58

Y

U1 TQ

Andrews

0.43

0.58

N

U1 Tip

Watanabe et al.

1.16

0.57

Y

U1 TQ

Watanabe et al.

1.61

0.57

Y

U1 Tip

Sebata

0.35

0.68

N

U1 TQ

Sebata

0.45

0.68

N

U1 Tip

Currim and Wadkar

0.64

0.62

Y

U1 TQ

Currim and Wadkar

0.63

0.62

Y

U1 Tip

Doodamani et al.

0.32

0.59

N

U1 TQ

Doodamani et al.

10.79

0.59

Y

U3 Tip

Andrews

0.07

0.58

N

U3 TQ

Andrews

2.72

0.58

Y

U3 Tip

Watanabe et al.

0.49

0.57

N

U3 TQ

Watanabe et al.

2.11

0.57

Y

U3 Tip

Sebata

0.25

0.68

N

U3 TQ

Sebata

0.71

0.68

Y

U3 Tip

Currim and Wadkar

1.47

0.62

Y

U3 TQ

Currim and Wadkar

1.85

0.62

Y

U3 Tip

Doodamani et al.

1.48

0.59

Y

U3 TQ

Doodamani et al.

13.75

0.59

Y

U4 Tip

Andrews

4.28

0.58

Y

U4 TQ

Andrews

0.08

0.58

N

U4 Tip

Watanabe et al.

2.77

0.57

Y

U4 TQ

Watanabe et al.

0.45

0.57

N

U4 Tip

Sebata

1.98

0.68

Y

U4 TQ

Sebata

0.33

0.68

N

U4 Tip

Currim and Wadkar

1.64

0.62

Y

U4 TQ

Currim and Wadkar

0.05

0.62

N

U4 Tip

Doodamani et al.

8.68

0.59

Y

U4 TQ

Doodamani et al.

0.59

0.59

Y

U5 Tip

Andrews

1.20

0.58

Y

U5 TQ

Andrews

0.07

0.58

N

U5 Tip

Watanabe et al.

0.06

0.57

N

U5 TQ

Watanabe et al.

0.33

0.57

N

U5 Tip

Sebata

0.32

0.68

N

U5 TQ

Sebata

0.34

0.68

N

U5 Tip

Currim and Wadkar

0.00

0.62

N

U5 TQ

Currim and Wadkar

0.26

0.62

N

U5 Tip

Doodamani et al.

2.79

0.59

Y

U5 TQ

Doodamani et al.

1.03

0.59

Y

U6 Tip

Andrews

1.28

0.58

Y

U6 TQ

Andrews

0.91

0.58

Y

U6 Tip

Watanabe et al.

0.91

0.57

Y

U6 TQ

Watanabe et al.

1.25

0.57

Y

U6 Tip

Sebata

0.60

0.68

N

U6 TQ

Sebata

2.01

0.68

Y

U6 Tip

Currim and Wadkar

0.48

0.62

N

U6 TQ

Currim and Wadkar

0.61

0.62

N

U6 Tip

Doodamani et al.

1.83

0.59

Y

U6 TQ

Doodamani et al.

0.21

0.59

N

L1 Tip

Andrews

1.25

0.58

Y

L1 TQ

Andrews

0.10

0.58

N

L1 Tip

Watanabe et al.

0.17

0.57

N

L1 TQ

Watanabe et al.

0.48

0.57

N

L1 Tip

Sebata

1.29

0.68

Y

L1 TQ

Sebata

0.94

0.68

Y

L1 Tip

Currim and Wadkar

1.36

0.62

Y

L1 TQ

Currim and Wadkar

0.79

0.62

Y

L1 Tip

Doodamani et al.

1.56

0.59

Y

L1 TQ

Doodamani et al.

8.37

0.59

Y

L2 Tip

Andrews

1.33

0.58

Y

L2 TQ

Andrews

0.38

0.58

N

L2 Tip

Watanabe et al.

0.04

0.57

N

L2 TQ

Watanabe et al.

0.50

0.57

N

L2 Tip

Sebata

1.65

0.68

Y

L2 TQ

Sebata

0.68

0.68

Y

L2 Tip

Currim and Wadkar

1.38

0.62

Y

L2 TQ

Currim and Wadkar

0.76

0.62

Y

L2 Tip

Doodamani et al.

1.87

0.59

Y

L2 TQ

Doodamani et al.

8.60

0.59

Y

L3 Tip

Andrews

0.76

0.58

Y

L3 TQ

Andrews

0.29

0.58

N

L3 Tip

Watanabe et al.

0.25

0.57

N

L3 TQ

Watanabe et al.

0.09

0.57

N

L3 Tip

Sebata

0.76

0.68

Y

L3 TQ

Sebata

1.41

0.68

Y

L3 Tip

Currim and Wadkar

1.65

0.62

Y

L3 TQ

Currim and Wadkar

0.46

0.62

N

L3 Tip

Doodamani et al.

1.43

0.59

Y

L3 TQ

Doodamani et al.

6.95

0.59

Y

L4 Tip

Andrews

1.02

0.58

Y

L4 TQ

Andrews

0.33

0.58

N

L4 Tip

Watanabe et al.

0.38

0.57

N

L4 TQ

Watanabe et al.

0.19

0.57

N

L4 Tip

Sebata

0.16

0.68

N

L4 TQ

Sebata

0.26

0.68

N

L4 Tip

Currim and Wadkar

0.99

0.62

Y

L4 TQ

Currim and Wadkar

0.36

0.62

N

L4 Tip

Doodamani et al.

1.29

0.59

Y

L4 TQ

Doodamani et al.

5.92

0.59

Y

L5 Tip

Andrews

1.52

0.58

Y

L5 TQ

Andrews

0.25

0.58

N

L5 Tip

Watanabe et al.

0.06

0.57

N

L5 TQ

Watanabe et al.

0.13

0.57

N

L5 Tip

Sebata

0.77

0.68

Y

L5 TQ

Sebata

0.04

0.68

N

L5 Tip

Currim and Wadkar

0.77

0.62

Y

L5 TQ

Currim and Wadkar

0.35

0.62

N

L5 Tip

Doodamani et al.

1.61

0.59

Y

L5 TQ

Doodamani et al.

5.42

0.59

Y

L6 Tip

Andrews

1.96

0.58

Y

L6 TQ

Andrews

0.27

0.58

N

L6 Tip

Watanabe et al.

0.84

0.57

Y

L6 TQ

Watanabe et al.

0.23

0.57

N

L6 Tip

Sebata

0.11

0.68

N

L6 TQ

Sebata

1.14

0.68

Y

L6 Tip

Currim and Wadkar

1.09

0.62

Y

L6 TQ

Currim and Wadkar

0.38

0.62

N

L6 Tip

Doodamani et al.

2.22

0.59

Y

L6 TQ

Doodamani et al.

6.76

0.59

Y

In out U1

Andrews

1.19

0.58

Y

In out L1

Andrews

0.36

0.58

N

In out U1

Watanabe et al.

0.58

0.57

Y

In out L1

Watanabe et al.

1.74

0.57

Y

In out U1

Currim and Wadkar

0.30

0.62

N

In out L1

Currim and Wadkar

0.93

0.62

Y

In out U3

Andrews

1.25

0.58

Y

In out L2

Andrews

0.81

0.58

Y

In out U3

Watanabe et al.

1.82

0.57

Y

In out L2

Watanabe et al.

0.34

0.57

N

In out U3

Currim and Wadkar

0.39

0.62

N

In out L2

Currim and Wadkar

0.29

0.62

N

In out U4

Andrews

3.07

0.58

Y

In out L3

Andrews

1.00

0.58

Y

In out U4

Watanabe et al.

2.43

0.57

Y

In out L3

Watanabe et al.

1.58

0.57

Y

In out U4

Currim and Wadkar

0.91

0.62

Y

In out L3

Currim and Wadkar

0.66

0.62

Y

In out U5

Andrews

3.46

0.58

Y

In out L4

Andrews

1.45

0.58

Y

In out U5

Watanabe et al.

1.47

0.57

Y

In out L4

Watanabe et al.

2.15

0.57

Y

In out U5

Currim and Wadkar

1.14

0.62

Y

In out L4

Currim and Wadkar

0.81

0.62

Y

In out U6

Andrews

3.85

0.58

Y

In out L5

Andrews

2.71

0.58

Y

In out U6

Watanabe et al.

0.59

0.57

Y

In out L5

Watanabe et al.

1.54

0.57

Y

In out U6

Currim and Wadkar

1.41

0.62

Y

In out L5

Currim and Wadkar

1.22

0.62

Y

     

In out L6

Andrews

3.42

0.58

Y

     

In out L6

Watanabe et al.

1.13

0.57

Y

     

In out L6

Currim and Wadkar

1.90

0.62

Y

  1. TQ, torque; Y, yes; N, no.
Back to article page