Skip to main content

Advertisement

Table 2 Comparison of the current study tip torque and in-out values with other studies

From: Optimal parameters for final position of teeth in space closure in case of a missing upper lateral incisor

Measure Author EmpiricalD MinD Difference Measure Author EmpiricalD MinD Difference
U1 Tip Andrews 0.73 0.58 Y U1 TQ Andrews 0.43 0.58 N
U1 Tip Watanabe et al. 1.16 0.57 Y U1 TQ Watanabe et al. 1.61 0.57 Y
U1 Tip Sebata 0.35 0.68 N U1 TQ Sebata 0.45 0.68 N
U1 Tip Currim and Wadkar 0.64 0.62 Y U1 TQ Currim and Wadkar 0.63 0.62 Y
U1 Tip Doodamani et al. 0.32 0.59 N U1 TQ Doodamani et al. 10.79 0.59 Y
U3 Tip Andrews 0.07 0.58 N U3 TQ Andrews 2.72 0.58 Y
U3 Tip Watanabe et al. 0.49 0.57 N U3 TQ Watanabe et al. 2.11 0.57 Y
U3 Tip Sebata 0.25 0.68 N U3 TQ Sebata 0.71 0.68 Y
U3 Tip Currim and Wadkar 1.47 0.62 Y U3 TQ Currim and Wadkar 1.85 0.62 Y
U3 Tip Doodamani et al. 1.48 0.59 Y U3 TQ Doodamani et al. 13.75 0.59 Y
U4 Tip Andrews 4.28 0.58 Y U4 TQ Andrews 0.08 0.58 N
U4 Tip Watanabe et al. 2.77 0.57 Y U4 TQ Watanabe et al. 0.45 0.57 N
U4 Tip Sebata 1.98 0.68 Y U4 TQ Sebata 0.33 0.68 N
U4 Tip Currim and Wadkar 1.64 0.62 Y U4 TQ Currim and Wadkar 0.05 0.62 N
U4 Tip Doodamani et al. 8.68 0.59 Y U4 TQ Doodamani et al. 0.59 0.59 Y
U5 Tip Andrews 1.20 0.58 Y U5 TQ Andrews 0.07 0.58 N
U5 Tip Watanabe et al. 0.06 0.57 N U5 TQ Watanabe et al. 0.33 0.57 N
U5 Tip Sebata 0.32 0.68 N U5 TQ Sebata 0.34 0.68 N
U5 Tip Currim and Wadkar 0.00 0.62 N U5 TQ Currim and Wadkar 0.26 0.62 N
U5 Tip Doodamani et al. 2.79 0.59 Y U5 TQ Doodamani et al. 1.03 0.59 Y
U6 Tip Andrews 1.28 0.58 Y U6 TQ Andrews 0.91 0.58 Y
U6 Tip Watanabe et al. 0.91 0.57 Y U6 TQ Watanabe et al. 1.25 0.57 Y
U6 Tip Sebata 0.60 0.68 N U6 TQ Sebata 2.01 0.68 Y
U6 Tip Currim and Wadkar 0.48 0.62 N U6 TQ Currim and Wadkar 0.61 0.62 N
U6 Tip Doodamani et al. 1.83 0.59 Y U6 TQ Doodamani et al. 0.21 0.59 N
L1 Tip Andrews 1.25 0.58 Y L1 TQ Andrews 0.10 0.58 N
L1 Tip Watanabe et al. 0.17 0.57 N L1 TQ Watanabe et al. 0.48 0.57 N
L1 Tip Sebata 1.29 0.68 Y L1 TQ Sebata 0.94 0.68 Y
L1 Tip Currim and Wadkar 1.36 0.62 Y L1 TQ Currim and Wadkar 0.79 0.62 Y
L1 Tip Doodamani et al. 1.56 0.59 Y L1 TQ Doodamani et al. 8.37 0.59 Y
L2 Tip Andrews 1.33 0.58 Y L2 TQ Andrews 0.38 0.58 N
L2 Tip Watanabe et al. 0.04 0.57 N L2 TQ Watanabe et al. 0.50 0.57 N
L2 Tip Sebata 1.65 0.68 Y L2 TQ Sebata 0.68 0.68 Y
L2 Tip Currim and Wadkar 1.38 0.62 Y L2 TQ Currim and Wadkar 0.76 0.62 Y
L2 Tip Doodamani et al. 1.87 0.59 Y L2 TQ Doodamani et al. 8.60 0.59 Y
L3 Tip Andrews 0.76 0.58 Y L3 TQ Andrews 0.29 0.58 N
L3 Tip Watanabe et al. 0.25 0.57 N L3 TQ Watanabe et al. 0.09 0.57 N
L3 Tip Sebata 0.76 0.68 Y L3 TQ Sebata 1.41 0.68 Y
L3 Tip Currim and Wadkar 1.65 0.62 Y L3 TQ Currim and Wadkar 0.46 0.62 N
L3 Tip Doodamani et al. 1.43 0.59 Y L3 TQ Doodamani et al. 6.95 0.59 Y
L4 Tip Andrews 1.02 0.58 Y L4 TQ Andrews 0.33 0.58 N
L4 Tip Watanabe et al. 0.38 0.57 N L4 TQ Watanabe et al. 0.19 0.57 N
L4 Tip Sebata 0.16 0.68 N L4 TQ Sebata 0.26 0.68 N
L4 Tip Currim and Wadkar 0.99 0.62 Y L4 TQ Currim and Wadkar 0.36 0.62 N
L4 Tip Doodamani et al. 1.29 0.59 Y L4 TQ Doodamani et al. 5.92 0.59 Y
L5 Tip Andrews 1.52 0.58 Y L5 TQ Andrews 0.25 0.58 N
L5 Tip Watanabe et al. 0.06 0.57 N L5 TQ Watanabe et al. 0.13 0.57 N
L5 Tip Sebata 0.77 0.68 Y L5 TQ Sebata 0.04 0.68 N
L5 Tip Currim and Wadkar 0.77 0.62 Y L5 TQ Currim and Wadkar 0.35 0.62 N
L5 Tip Doodamani et al. 1.61 0.59 Y L5 TQ Doodamani et al. 5.42 0.59 Y
L6 Tip Andrews 1.96 0.58 Y L6 TQ Andrews 0.27 0.58 N
L6 Tip Watanabe et al. 0.84 0.57 Y L6 TQ Watanabe et al. 0.23 0.57 N
L6 Tip Sebata 0.11 0.68 N L6 TQ Sebata 1.14 0.68 Y
L6 Tip Currim and Wadkar 1.09 0.62 Y L6 TQ Currim and Wadkar 0.38 0.62 N
L6 Tip Doodamani et al. 2.22 0.59 Y L6 TQ Doodamani et al. 6.76 0.59 Y
In out U1 Andrews 1.19 0.58 Y In out L1 Andrews 0.36 0.58 N
In out U1 Watanabe et al. 0.58 0.57 Y In out L1 Watanabe et al. 1.74 0.57 Y
In out U1 Currim and Wadkar 0.30 0.62 N In out L1 Currim and Wadkar 0.93 0.62 Y
In out U3 Andrews 1.25 0.58 Y In out L2 Andrews 0.81 0.58 Y
In out U3 Watanabe et al. 1.82 0.57 Y In out L2 Watanabe et al. 0.34 0.57 N
In out U3 Currim and Wadkar 0.39 0.62 N In out L2 Currim and Wadkar 0.29 0.62 N
In out U4 Andrews 3.07 0.58 Y In out L3 Andrews 1.00 0.58 Y
In out U4 Watanabe et al. 2.43 0.57 Y In out L3 Watanabe et al. 1.58 0.57 Y
In out U4 Currim and Wadkar 0.91 0.62 Y In out L3 Currim and Wadkar 0.66 0.62 Y
In out U5 Andrews 3.46 0.58 Y In out L4 Andrews 1.45 0.58 Y
In out U5 Watanabe et al. 1.47 0.57 Y In out L4 Watanabe et al. 2.15 0.57 Y
In out U5 Currim and Wadkar 1.14 0.62 Y In out L4 Currim and Wadkar 0.81 0.62 Y
In out U6 Andrews 3.85 0.58 Y In out L5 Andrews 2.71 0.58 Y
In out U6 Watanabe et al. 0.59 0.57 Y In out L5 Watanabe et al. 1.54 0.57 Y
In out U6 Currim and Wadkar 1.41 0.62 Y In out L5 Currim and Wadkar 1.22 0.62 Y
      In out L6 Andrews 3.42 0.58 Y
      In out L6 Watanabe et al. 1.13 0.57 Y
      In out L6 Currim and Wadkar 1.90 0.62 Y
  1. TQ, torque; Y, yes; N, no.